Friday, May 29, 2015

Integrating Omnichannel Retail: Looking Beyond Your Four Walls to Stay Ahead of the Curve

By Peter Zaballos — May 27, 2015

As far as consumers are concerned, the way you do anything is the way you do everything. And how you go about delivering the total shopping experience consumers demand is more visible now than ever before. That’s why leading retailers, suppliers, manufacturers and 3PLs are transforming their businesses by joining the omnichannel revolution. Their goal? To create the seamless shopping experience today’s consumers expect.
 
Whether they’re in stores, online, responding to emails, viewing promotions on mobile devices or all of the above, consumers truly are defining the shopping experience, and they want real service, not lip service. That means:
 
  • Robust product information
  • Accurate inventory information
  • Competitive prices
  • Social validation
  • Convenient fulfillment
  • Effortless returns
 
Meeting these needs doesn’t have to be enormously complex or expensive. Many retailers are creating a unified, comprehensive, customer-centric process by merging their systems and aligning their front- and back-office functions. But the leading retailers aren’t stopping there. They’re partnering with their suppliers and other trading partners to reinvent retail from the ground up.
 

Omnichannel retail: The possibilities—and aisles—are endless

Industry experts and consumers agree: Retail has changed more in the past decade than over the last century. Here are three reasons:
 
  • E-commerce. Not long ago, consumers did nearly all their shopping in stores, which is where retailers put their inventory. Then, in the mid-2000s, as e-commerce gained traction, retailers moved their inventory to their warehouses. Now, as channels continue to merge, those same retailers are filling orders differently: some have suppliers ship direct to retail stores for consumer pickup, others ship direct to consumer homes, and still others use a combination of these methods.
 
  • Mobile. According to Enhancing the Retail Omnichannel Customer Experience, a study conducted by Forrester Consulting on behalf of SPS Commerce, one-fifth of all consumers use their mobile phones for shopping-related tasks while in physical stores. Of that group, nearly 50% rely on their in-store mobile experiences to drive their purchase decisions; they compare prices, look up product and warranty information, read customer reviews, search for coupons and more. And now, with digital payment services such as Apple Pay, those same consumers are using their mobile phones to pay for their purchases.
 
  • Internet-of-Things. The emerging category of wearable devices is already having an impact, and with the highly anticipated introduction of the Apple Watch later this year, that impact is expected to explode. Not only will wearables open a new channel, they will open new opportunities for targeted promotions, behavior tracking and customer service. They will also open up opportunities for more retailer and third-party apps.
 

Mastering the Amazon Effect

It’s a given that retailers want to compete with or emulate Amazon. But if the focus remains solely on Amazon, the key opportunity will be missed. The real “effect” to focus on is the powerful role digital shopping and exploration is having on retailing overall by enabling consumers to buy what they want, how they want, when they want, and to have all purchases delivered quickly to wherever they want. Now, with nearly limitless information available at the swipe of a finger or on their wrists—information that guides and informs purchasing decisions—consumers are demanding faster, better and less expensive shopping experiences.
 
As the Forrester Consulting research study makes clear, retailers must change their business processes and systems in order to support how consumers are shopping right now, which is 100% omnichannel. In fact, what we see in the market today is retailing’s adjustment to this. That’s why embracing digital shopping and exploration has become so important. It’s a way for retailers to move beyond the four walls of their physical stores.
 
It’s also a way to increase sales, which retailers can do by expanding product offerings on their websites and in their apps. When they choose suppliers willing to ship direct to consumers, they don’t even have to own the inventory or warehouse, package or ship it. What’s more, if those suppliers are willing to carry more products or an expanded product assortment, sales increase further, as they do when suppliers provide photos, videos, consumer reviews, warranty information, shipping details and other information.
 
The result is a win-win for both retailers and suppliers.
 
But how do retailers find and manage such suppliers? One way is via network-based supply chains, sometimes referred to as Retail Business Networks.
 
Just as social networks such as LinkedIn and Facebook have changed how individuals, brands and companies connect with one another, network-based supply chains are changing the way suppliers, vendors and 3PLs connect with one another. The cloud enables them to share information and integrate operations. It also enables them to capitalize on relationships in order to make the most of what’s happening right this minute, whether that’s a snowstorm, a hot new movie or a trending item on Pinterest.
 

3 Ways to incorporate Omnichannel 


How do you begin to incorporate omnichannel retail solutions in your separate-channel world? Here are three ways:
 
1: Capture robust product data.
Today’s consumers want detailed information in order to make well-informed purchase decisions. Some companies do a good job of providing this information, others don’t—but make no mistake, consumers no longer have patience for shopping experiences that lack sufficient product information.
 
You can see for yourself by shopping for Nike’s LeBron men’s basketball shoes. On Nike.com, you’ll find color photos, a detailed product description, a comprehensive list of benefits, dozens of consumer reviews and even a video of LeBron playing basketball wearing his signature shoes. Contrast that with amazon.com, where you’ll find far less information: a few photos, a list of bullets, no benefits and only a handful of reviews.
 
If you were a consumer, where would you shop—on a site that gave you complete item information or the one that made you fill in the blanks?
 
2: Make sure the data is accurate.
Consumers expect—and deserve—accurate product data. When they don’t get it, they take their business elsewhere. That’s exactly what one of my colleagues did recently when shopping for a refrigerator. She’d been to a national big box store and had seen a model she liked. A few days later, she went online to verify the model’s dimensions.
 
As you can imagine, dimensions are one of a refrigerator’s most important product attributes: the one you buy has to fit into a pre-determined space.
 
What did she find? That the refrigerator she was considering measured 1” x 1” x 1.” Her reaction: Either this is the world’s smallest refrigerator or the retailer didn’t get the dimensions right. No surprise, she took her business elsewhere.
 
This is just one example of why accurate data is so important. With it, you build trusted relationships. Without it, you lose customers. You also increase returns because when consumers don’t have access to complete and accurate product data, they often end up being disappointed with their purchases.
 
3: Figure out how to manage returns.
One of my SPS Commerce colleagues once placed an online order for 15 pairs of shoes—five different models in three sizes each. The retailer was happy—until my colleague returned all but one pair. As much as a third of all Internet sales are returned, according to retail consultancy Kurt Salmon. And the tide of goods flowing back to retailers is rising: United Parcel Service expects returns to jump 15% this season.
 
In the past, most retailers directed consumers to send unwanted merchandise to a central returned-goods center. There, the item collected dust until someone decided to sell it at a discount or pack it up and send it back to the vendor. Today, forward-thinking retailers, suppliers and third-party logistics firms are developing an important competitive advantage by having consumers ship returns directly back the vendor. Instructions and mailing labels for doing so are often printed on packing slips; all consumers have to do is slap the label on the box and ship it off.
 
The retail world has changed. And it’s bound to continue changing as new technologies enable greater consumer control. But what won’t change is the position consumers hold in driving their own shopping experiences. The retailers who understand this are streamlining, integrating, synthesizing—and winning. Join them by embracing omnichannel today.
Retail marketing is changing. Today, success means connecting with your most important customer: the omni-channel shopper. Here we detail the three ways retailers can reach this shopper by measuring behavior, providing localized information, and creating the right organizational structure.
Written by
Julie Krueger
Published in
March 2015
Topics
The way we think about and approach retail marketing is changing. Today, success means reaching consumers wherever they are, on whatever device they may be using. Increasingly, that means smartphones. According to Google data, for much of the 2014 holiday season, mobile shopping clicks exceeded those on the desktop as shoppers made their purchase decisions on the go. And people are no longer discriminating between mobile and desktop when it comes to shopping—whether that's in a store or on an e-commerce site. This is creating new realities for retailers, as we've seen from our recent research with Ipsos MediaCT and Sterling Brands. Chief among them is the fact that digital doesn't just drive e-commerce; it gets people in the store. And this influence doesn't end at the entrance to the store: 71% of shoppers who use smartphones for research in-store say that it's become an important part of the experience. Smartphones are the new personal shopping assistant for people once they're inside.
As digital continues to touch every step of the customer journey, multi-channel retailers who operate both e-commerce and in-store channels are having to take note. They're changing the way they think about omni-channel shoppers (for instance, Banana Republic customers who shop both online and in-store) and what their shopping behavior means for the overall business. The most sophisticated retailers are ensuring their marketing strategies are geared toward enabling customers to convert onany channel. Why? Because they realize that a shopper who buys from them in-store and online is their most valuable kind of customer. According to a 2015 study by IDC, these shoppers have a 30% higher lifetime value than those who shop using only one channel.
Retailers can reap the revenue benefits of omni-channel shopping, but only if they know how to attract and connect with these highly desirable consumers. Doing so requires a deep knowledge of how these shoppers behave. It also requires structuring the company to be able to act on these insights. Let's be honest: This is much easier said than done.
Using examples from retailers who have started to make this shift, we detail the three keys to connecting with omni-channel shopping: measure behavior, provide relevant and local retail information, and create an organizational structure that supports omni-channel marketing.

Measure cross-device and online-to-store shopping behavior

To engage omni-channel shoppers, you first need to understand who they are. At a basic level, this means knowing important factors about the customer such as gender, demographic, location, website browsing habits, search habits, and where they shop in-store. But that's not enough.
Top retailers understand their customer in even greater detail. They measure the influence of all touchpoints on a customer's journey to purchase—online, offline, and across devices—using sophisticated measurement systems. These attribution platforms track the customer's journey through each channel—TV, display, search, email, and direct mail—providing a holistic view of how a valuable customer makes a purchase.
Using sophisticated measurement, leading retailers can answer important questions about their ideal customer. For example, does she shop across a mix of online and offline channels before making a purchase? Is she likely to visit a retailer's mobile site? Has her purchase frequency increased as a result of a specific marketing campaign? Is mobile assisting her in-store purchase? What marketing channel or ad type would be most helpful in drawing her into a nearby store? Where can a retailer find more customers like her?
Armed with better measurement insights, retailers can, for example, better use online channels to draw shoppers into their stores. "One in four who click on mobile search ads end up in a store, so we've realized that the in-store experience needs to continue to build on that bridge we've made in digital," says Evan Conway, Sprint's vice president of digital. And Sprint was able to understand the full, cross-channel value of its search advertising as well: Sprint's own data shows that for every sale that paid search ads generate online, paid search ads drive five in-store sales.
Sears Hometown and Outlet Stores and PetSmart, for example, are usingGoogle AdWords' Store Visits to see whether their ads are driving in-store visits and purchases. By measuring valuable actions beyond clicks—phone calls, cross-device conversions, and even store visits—retailers can see how their digital efforts are affecting in-store sales. "We've always known that our digital efforts had an impact on store traffic, but it was difficult to quantify. These tools have helped us both with our ad formats and in our evaluation of their impact," says David Buckley, chief marketing officer of Sears Hometown and Outlet Stores. PetSmart, too, found that search ads had a direct impact on store visits. According to Google's Store Visits metric in AdWords, 10–18% of all clicks on its search ads resulted in an in-store visit within 30 days.

Provide omni-channel shoppers with relevant, local information

Once you begin to understand the relationship between digital and in-store for your omni-channel shoppers, it's important to think about reaching them wherever they are and making the experience seamless. Why? Well, according to our recent research, three in four shoppers who find local retail information in search results helpful are more likely to visit stores.
Online-to-offline ad formats can improve the shopping experience for your customers, making it easy to see your store location, products, and available inventory from within the search ad itself. Sears Hometown and Outlet Stores, for example, uses local inventory ads (LIAs) to show customers searching online for a particular item exactly where it is available at a nearby store location, along with local store hours, and other helpful information like directions. According to Sears Hometown and Outlet Stores, the result has been a 122% increase in store visits compared to using only Product Listing Ads (which don't include local store information).
"If people are searching for a product on their phones, there is nothing more targeted than serving that item with a picture, description, and price, while letting customers know exactly how far they are located from the product," says Buckley. Easy access to this type of information means a smoother path to a brand's front door.
And these results have helped extend the reach of Sears Hometown and Outlet Stores' advertising budget, driving $8 of in-store sales for each dollar invested online. "When we compared our most recent performance of local inventory ads with offline media typically used to drive store sales, such as a recent broadcast television campaign, the local inventory ads returned in-store sales at more than 5X the rate of TV advertising for each dollar spent," Buckley reveals.
Office Depot also used LIAs to reach its growing base of omni-channel shoppers. "Local Inventory Ads provide us with a unique opportunity to offer products that customers are searching for and assure them there is inventory in a store nearby," says Christine Buscarino, vice president of ecommerce marketing for Office Depot, Inc. The result was a better shopping experience for its customers and a 3X higher return on digital marketing spend for the company.
Office Depot local retail ad

Create an organizational structure that supports omni-channel marketing

Once you've identified your most valuable customers—omni-channel shoppers—and you've started to understand their online-to-store behavior, it's time to take action on these insights and create that seamless shopping experience that leads to a sale. To do so, you'll need an organizational structure that supports you.
For most retailers, this means closer collaboration between your online and in-store marketing teams. Macy's has managed to do this successfully. The brand has adopted a unified approach to meeting its customers' needs across channels. "We continue to learn from our experiences and mold our business model around what our customers are telling us and how they are behaving so that we can continue to succeed in this environment. In many ways, this is a race to remain best-in-class—and to win with the customer," says Terry J. Lundgren, chairman and CEO at Macy's.
Because it now has a more complete view of the customer shopping experience across channels, Macy's sees its online and in-store marketing as a holistic entity to support the brand as a whole.
"That incentive of growing the number of omni-channel customers is something we have all shared over the past couple of years," says Jennifer Kasper, group vice president of digital media and multicultural marketing for Macy's.
"We used to have two separate, siloed budgets. We really have only one marketing budget. We look at the best way to spend that; whether it's digital or offline, we focus on how they work together to deliver the most sales and the best customer experience," says Serena Potter, group vice president of digital media strategy at Macy's.
The lesson here is to take a close look at how your employees and teams are set up to support omni-channel shopping behavior. In other words, you need to have the right metrics in place (an omni-channel mentality is key here) to incentivize employees to support the experience. If not, the organization could be hindering its own goals. Say, for example, e-commerce teams are rewarded only for online purchases. The likely result is that they won't have an incentive to run innovative digital-to-store campaigns that generate in-store sales. Likewise, make sure your store teams are rewarded for contributing to the sale, even when it ultimately happens online.

Moving forward to the omni-channel shopping era

Omni-channel shopping presents a dramatic shift in how we think about retail, but it's a change that comes with huge opportunity. Start your journey by understanding the specific traits of these shoppers. Get to know who they are and what propels them to shop online and in-store by using the tools that will help you measure online and offline purchases effectively across channels. Most important, give your customers what they're craving: instant, relevant information no matter where they are or what device they're using. Ultimately, though, it's your team structure, incentives, and measurement that together support the common goal of attracting more loyal, valuable omni-channel shoppers. By focusing on their wants and needs, you'll create a seamless shopping experience that's more likely to drive sales across your organization.

Expert Column: A Triple Bottom-line Solution to Grocers’ Food Waste

Teaming with food rescue org can help needy, save costs, boost sustainability

 By Lauren Palumbo, Lovin' Spoonfuls
Lovin' Spoonfuls Truck, Photo Courtesy of Katy Jordan
The statistics are staggering: 40 percent of food in the United States goes to waste. It's the single largest component of our landfills, and the retail value of wasted food in America is estimated at more than $165 billion per year.
For grocers and food retailers, that waste comes in the form of unsold, excess food. Large varieties of fresh produce and grains are continuously stocked to meet shoppers' high expectations that any and all items will be available and ripe – leaving imperfect, blemished foods to be culled from the shelves daily and thrown in the trash. The waste also comes in the form of close-dated perishables; unregulated sell-by dates prompt team members to pull products from the shelves.
As a result, tons of perishable products are wasted every day, in every part of the country. According to the National Resource Defense Council's most recent data, "in-store food losses in the United States totaled an estimated 43 billion pounds, equivalent to 10 percent of the total food supply at the retail level." Additionally, the USDA estimates that $15 billion of fruits and vegetables alone are tossed at retail locations annually.
Though retailers are no longer able to sell the food directly to their customers, the excess food still holds tremendous value. Today 49 million Americans struggle daily with food insecurity, which the USDA defines as having "limited or uncertain availability of nutritionally adequate and safe foods." Capturing that perishable product by working with a food rescue partner provides an easy and scalable triple bottom-line solution for grocers and food retailers: support community members in need, save costs on disposal fees and increase sustainability.
Hunger Is a Distribution Problem
Traditional hunger relief methods focus on nonperishables, and historically retailers haven't had an outlet for culled perishables such as fruits, vegetables, dairy, proteins and prepared foods.
These days, food rescue organizations provide a solution to upcycle food by directly connecting grocery stores, produce wholesalers and farms to local meal programs and social service entities serving those in need. "Rescued" perishable food is distributed daily and used immediately by soup kitchens, homeless shelters, food pantries, senior centers and other organizations, thereby providing much-needed healthy meals for food-insecure families and individuals.
There's no liability risk to grocers. In 1996, President Bill Clinton signed the Bill Emerson Good Samaritan Act to encourage donation of food and grocery products to nonprofit organizations for distribution to individuals in need. The law provides businesses with protection from liability when food donations are made to a nonprofit organization, including protection from civil and criminal liability should the product donated in good faith later cause harm to the recipient.
Bottom-line Impact
Establishing a food rescue program opens grocers up to numerous cost-savings initiatives. By allowing fewer products to end up in Dumpsters and compost bins, businesses can see a reduction in waste removal fees. By keeping a ton or more of waste out of local landfills each week, grocers can save upwards of $200 regularly on disposal fees, netting thousands in savings each year.
Businesses are also eligible for enhanced federal tax deductions when the product is donated to a qualified nonprofit. For example, IRS Revenue Code 170(e)(3) allows qualified business taxpayers to deduct the cost to produce the rescued food, and half the difference between the cost and full market value of it.
Boosting Sustainability
Beyond the bottom line, food rescue can play a valuable role in increasing a retailer's sustainability efforts. The environmental impact of food waste is enormous:
  • $750 million is spent each year in the United States to incinerate and dispose of unwanted food.
  • 300 million barrels of oil and one-quarter of total freshwater are used each year to produce food that's ultimately wasted.
  • Decomposing food in landfills emits methane, a gas that has effect on global climate change that’s nearly 25 times more potent than that of carbon dioxide.
By keeping food out of the waste stream, businesses can ensure that the resources put into growing and transporting food aren't wasted. Furthermore, a well-organized and -executed food rescue program showcases a grocer's commitment to reducing its environmental footprint while broadening access to healthier food options in the local community it serves.
Food Rescue in Action
In 2013, Lovin' Spoonfuls, a greater Boston-based food rescue organization, began a partnership with Scarborough, Maine-based Hannaford Supermarkets, adding collections at two of the Delhaize America chain's locations in Waltham and Norwood, Mass. To date, more than 200,000 pounds of fresh, healthy food have been saved from these stores. The 100-plus tons of product diverted from landfills means that tens of thousands of people were given access to better food options, and 380 tons of greenhouse gases weren't emitted.
The food rescue solution was carefully crafted by Lovin' Spoonfuls and designed specifically to meet Hannaford's business, needs, and schedule. The organization provided training and resources to Hannaford's teams as they worked to roll out a modern donation system, and to ensure that the business is maximizing its impact.
A 2014 report by the nonprofit Manomet Center for Conservation Sciences, in Manomet, Mass., found that Hannaford saved more than $15 million annually by implementing sustainability practices (including food rescue), while also diverting 125 million pounds of waste from landfills and keeping more than 430 million pounds of greenhouse gases from being emitted.
Triple Bottom-line Solutions
A partnership between a food retailer and a food rescue organization offers a powerful impact at every level. Together, you're feeding thousands of people in the communities where you live, promoting healthy eating habits for those who don't have ready access, simplifying sustainability for producers and retailers and lowering costs.

Monday, May 25, 2015

Gartner Announces Their Supply Chain Top 25 Rankings For 2015

Amazon Takes the Top Spot in Top 25 Rankings; Apple and P&G Move into New Masters Category Winners Revealed at Gartner Supply Chain Executive Conference in Phoenix, AZ. By 24/7 Staff


1 

Creating a Cloud Roadmap for Your Enterprise
Planning a strategic move to the cloud can be challenging. To help your cloud planning effort, NetSuite is pleased to provide you with this newsletter featuring research from Gartner.

Gartner, Inc. has released the findings from its 11th annual Supply Chain Top 25, identifying global supply chain leaders and highlighting their best practices.
Analysts announced the findings from this year’s research at the Gartner Supply Chain Executive Conference, which is being held through today at the JW Marriott Desert Ridge Resort and Spa in Phoenix, AZ.
“2015 marks the 11th year of our annual Supply Chain Top 25 ranking,” said Stan Aronow, research vice president at Gartner. “In this edition of the Supply Chain Top 25, we have several longtime leaders with new lessons to share and a number of more recent entrants from the high-tech, consumer products, retail and industrial sectors.”
The top five include three from last year - Amazon, McDonald’s and Unilever - one returning leader, Intel, and a newcomer to this elite group, Inditex (see Table 1).
Three companies rejoined the list this year after a lengthy hiatus, with L’Oréal at No. 22, Toyota at No. 24 and Home Depot at No. 25. Those familiar with Gartner’s Supply Chain Top 25 may wonder why perennial leaders Apple and P&G are not included on this year’s list.
“This year we are introducing a brand new category to highlight the accomplishments and capabilities of long-term leaders. We are, therefore, recognizing those companies that have consistently had top five composite scores for at least seven out of the last 10 years and placing them into a ‘masters’ category, separate from the overall Supply Chain Top 25 list,” said Mr. Aronow. “In this the inaugural year for supply chain masters, we want to recognize two companies demonstrating sustained leadership: Apple and P&G.”
Mr. Aronow said that both Apple and P&G have made major contributions to the supply chain profession over the years. P&G was one of the first to characterize and embed the concept of a consumer-driven supply chain, and Apple, defining the very notion of a “solution” supply chain, blazed new trails with its demand creation capabilities.
Table 1. The Gartner Supply Chain Top 25 for 2015
RankCompanyPeer Opinion 1(200 voters)(25%)
Gartner Opinion 1 (35 voters) (25%)
Three- Year Weighted ROA2 (25%)
Inventory Turns 3(15%)
Three-Year Weighted Revenue Growth 4 (10%)Composite Score 5
1Amazon3,3944680.0%8.7 21.7%  5.32
2  McDonald’s  1,626  283  14.6%  157.3  -0.2%  5.23
3  Unilever  1,996  619  11.3%  6.7  -0.2%  5.15
4  Intel  1,064  481  12.1%  5.0  2.4%  4.09
5  Inditex  1,003  297  17.0%  3.8  8.8%  4.04
6  Cisco Systems  1,147  500  8.4%  12.6  1.5%  4.01
7  H&M  809  89  26.6%  3.7  12.8%  4.01
8  Samsung Electronics  1,568  330  10.5%  17.7  0.5%  3.91
9  Colgate-Palmolive  1,034  318  17.8%  5.0  0.6%  3.91
10  Nike  1,369  214  14.5%  4.1  10.7%  3.78
11  Coca-Cola  1,938  287  8.9%  5.4  -1.0%  3.49
12  Starbucks  1,215  174  13.0%  6.8  11.6%  3.48
13  Walmart  1,794  259  8.4%  7.8  2.5%  3.39
14  3M  1,161  150  14.9%  4.2  2.7%  3.09
15  PepsiCo  890  330  8.9%  8.3  0.3%  3.04
16  Seagate Technology  176  114  19.9%  10.8  3.9%  2.99
17  Nestlé  1,123  244  9.9%  5.1  2.0%  2.93
18  Lenovo Group  771  218  3.9%  12.8  18.9%  2.89
19  Qualcomm  218  50  15.5%  8.8  17.8%  2.85
20  Kimberly-Clark  819  243  10.5%  5.9  0.8%  2.76
21  Johnson & Johnson  1,192  139  11.1%  2.8  4.6%  2.73
22  L’Oréal  749  118  12.5%  2.9  2.9%  2.41
23  Cummins  148  149  11.5%  5.2  4.7%  2.16
24  Toyota Motor  1,322  23  3.6%  10.6  13.4%  2.16
25  Home Depot  268  44  14.1%  4.6  5.6%  2.11
Notes:
1. Gartner Opinion and Peer Opinion: Based on each panel’s forced-rank ordering against the definition of “DDVN orchestrator”
2. ROA: ((2014 net income/2014 total assets) * 50%) + ((2013 net income/2013 total assets) * 30%) + ((2012 net income/2012 total assets) * 20%)
3. Inventory Turns: 2014 cost of goods sold/2014 quarterly average inventory
4. Revenue Growth: ((change in revenue 2014-2013) * 50%) + ((change in revenue 2013-2012) * 30%) + ((change in revenue 2012-2011) * 20%)
5. Composite Score: (Peer Opinion * 25%) + (Gartner Research Opinion * 25%) + (ROA * 25%) + (Inventory Turns * 15%) + (Revenue Growth * 10%)
2014 data used where available. Where unavailable, latest available full-year data used. All raw data normalized to a 10-point scale prior to composite calculation. “Ranks” for tied composite scores are determined using next decimal point comparison.
Source: Gartner (May 2015)

Gartner Analysts Highlighted Three Standout Trends For Supply Chain Leaders In 2015:
Bimodal Supply Chain Strategies
Chief supply chain officers (CSCOs) and their teams face an environment where business models must change quickly, where the expectation is that they will spend as much or more time growing and innovating as they will streamlining and promoting efficiency. Gartner has termed this reality “bimodal.” Traditionally, supply chain executives have been successful because they were good at driving down costs. The leaders now realize they will be judged on cost containment as well as the ability to promote and support the top line.
Increased Customer Intimacy
Another trend is a focus on customer experience as a measured priority in supply chain organizations. Independent of the product being sold, leaders are focused on listening more closely to their customers and responding with innovative solutions.
“This year, we heard from more companies extending visibility and insight beyond first-line customers and moving on to the end users of their products. Their supply chains are not just collecting data concerning the details of the sale, but also the patterns of usage and resulting sentiment of the end user,” said Mr. Aronow. “Ultimately, pleasing customers with strong operational supply chain performance, when combined with improved solution performance, will lead to measurable improvements in customer satisfaction and contributions to the top line.
Emerging Digital Business Models
While still a nascent concept, the view on how supply chain can leverage digital capabilities to support new business models and improve broader value chain performance became clearer this year. Manufacturing is currently at the center of many digital capabilities and leading companies recognize that “the factory” is not just somewhere inside the four walls of the company or an outsource partner. Digital synchronization of manufacturing lines with upstream suppliers and other supply chain functions is where the business value starts to multiply.
The logistics function is not far behind manufacturing in terms of automation using sensors, gateways, tracking systems and business rules to predict and alert when there will be a variance to the current plan of record. Logistics control tower capabilities are not new, but when combined with more affordable sensors and computing power, they portend the democratization of deeper visibility that can reduce risk and improve both operating costs and customer-service levels for many companies.
More detailed analysis is available in the report “The Gartner Supply Chain Top 25 for 2015.”
About the Gartner Supply Chain Top 25
The Supply Chain Top 25 rankings comprise two main components: financial and opinion. Public financial data gives a view into how companies have performed in the past, while the opinion component provides an eye to potential and reflects future expected leadership, a crucial characteristic. These two components are combined into a total composite score.
Gartner analysts derive a master list of companies from the Fortune Global 500 and the Forbes Global 2000, with a revenue cutoff of $12 billion. Gartner then pares the combined list down to the manufacturing, retail and distribution sectors, thus eliminating certain industries, such as financial services and insurance.